About Us

Who We Are and How We Help

Proudly serving Texas and beyond with a mission to save you money, deliver honest guidance, and treat every client like family.

A Local Agency Built on Integrity, Growth, and Real Savings

Broken Spoke Insurance was founded on a simple idea: insurance should put people first, not profits. In 2017, we took over a long-standing agency and expanded it with one goal—to save clients money every year, no matter what. Our team’s commitment paid off, growing the agency fourfold and earning the trust of families and businesses across the Texas Panhandle and 14 other states. Today, our independent model means you get more choice, transparent advice, and support that goes beyond the sale.

Our Mission

Our mission is to save people money and help them feel confident in their coverage—year after year, renewal after renewal.

Values That Shape How We Show Up for You

Three businesspeople at a wooden table, reviewing a tablet. Indoor, with plants.

Dependability

We show up when you call, answer questions fast, and stay involved long after your policy is written. That’s why so many clients refer friends and family.

Integrity

You get honest advice and options that put your needs first—not sales quotas or carrier pressure. Every renewal, we search for new ways to keep your coverage strong and your rates competitive.

Community Focus

We live and work in the same Texas towns as our clients, support local causes, and serve neighbors across Stratford, Dalhart, Amarillo, and beyond.

Choice & Clarity

With more than 20 carrier partners, we can shop for policies that fit your life or business—always taking the time to explain your choices and coverage.

Black mountains with a flag on top, symbolizing a goal achieved.

Meet the Team That’s Here for You

Portrait of a smiling person in a blue patterned blouse outdoors with a blurred background

Jaime Johnson


Member Description

Button
Woman in a business suit with arms crossed, smiling confidently, in a modern office.

Brittany Johnson


Member Description

Button
Woman in a black blazer smiling outdoors against a blurred building background

Jennifer King


Member Description

Button
Smiling person in a black top leaning on a chair outdoors, with a blurred green background

Tiffiny Osborne


Member Description

Button
Woman in a business suit with arms crossed, smiling confidently, in a modern office.

Michelle Eising


Member Description

Button
Smiling woman in a green jacket leaning against a blue brick wall outdoors

Amanda Ritchie


Member Description

Button

A Commitment to the People We Serve

Broken Spoke Insurance supports clients across Texas, from Amarillo to San Antonio, with offices in Stratford, Dalhart, and Amarillo. Whether you’re in a rural farming community or a busy metro, we know the local risks, industry needs, and real-life challenges you face. Our agency is licensed in 15 states—including Oklahoma, New Mexico, and the wider South and Midwest—so you get the reach of a regional provider with Texas values at heart. Active in the community and proud Trusted Choice® members, we’re always working to give back where we live and work.

Couple smiles as a financial advisor presents documents in an office setting.

Make One Decision Today That Reduces Months of Stress

Choosing the right insurance shouldn’t feel like guesswork or a gamble. With Broken Spoke Insurance, you get real people, real advice, and honest answers at every step. Let’s talk about your needs and make your next move with confidence.